Redesigning your site without losing the rankings you already have
You are about to relaunch your site and wonder whether changing the page addresses will cost you your Google traffic. Here is what to keep, what to redirect and what to check.
You are about to relaunch your website. The new design is better, the new platform is easier to manage, and then someone asks the question that stops the project: “Will we lose our Google rankings?” It is a fair worry, and it is one of the most avoidable ways to damage a business site.
The short answer is that a redesign does not harm your search traffic by itself. What harms it is changing page addresses without telling Google and visitors where the pages went. Here is how I handle it.
Why addresses matter more than the design
Google knows your pages by their web addresses. Every address that has earned a place in search results, or has links pointing to it from other sites, carries history. If the old address stops working and nothing points to the new one, that history is gone, and the visitor lands on an error page.
The colours, the layout and the photos can all change without this problem. The addresses are the part to protect.
Before you change anything: make a list
Write down every page on the current site that matters. Not just the menu pages. Include old service pages, blog posts, location pages and anything people might have bookmarked or linked to.
- Export the list of pages from your current site, or from your sitemap.
- Open Search Console and note which pages actually get visits from search. Those are the ones you cannot afford to lose.
- Check which pages other sites link to. Any page with an outside link is worth protecting.
- Take a screenshot or a copy of the current titles and headings of the important pages, so you can compare after launch.
This list is the most useful thing in the whole project. Without it, nobody can tell afterwards what went missing.
The simplest rule: keep the address if you can
If a page still exists on the new site, the best option is to leave its address exactly as it was. No change, nothing to redirect, nothing to lose. A redesign often tempts people to tidy the structure, and sometimes that is worth it, but each change is a risk that has to be managed. Change an address only when you have a real reason.
When an address has to change: redirect it
If a page moves, set up a permanent redirect from the old address to the new one. Google explains how redirects work and when to use permanent ones, and it has a separate guide to moving a site with URL changes. A few practical points:
- Send each old page to the closest matching new page, not everything to the homepage.
- If a page is gone for good and nothing similar exists, it is fine to let it end. Just make that a choice, not an accident.
- Avoid chains, where the old address goes to a second address that goes to a third. One step is cleaner.
- Keep the redirects in place long term. They cost nothing to leave.
What to check on launch day
- Click through the list of important pages. Each old address should reach the right new page.
- Make sure the new site is not set to ask search engines to stay away. This setting is common on a staging copy, and it sometimes survives to launch.
- Check that your contact form, phone links and booking tools still work. Rankings are no use if the enquiry never arrives.
- Submit the new sitemap in Search Console.
What to expect afterwards
A short period of movement in the results after a relaunch is normal, even when everything was done correctly. Watch Search Console over the next few weeks. If important pages drop out entirely, go back to your list and look for the address that was missed. In my experience the problem is nearly always one of a handful of pages, and it is fixable once you can see which.
My view is that no redesign should go live without this list and a redirect plan, whoever builds it. If you are choosing someone to do it, ask them how they handle it. The answer tells you a lot, and I cover more of those questions in seven questions to ask before you hire a web designer. If your new site is also slow to load, this post on speed is worth reading before launch.
If you are planning a relaunch and want it done without losing what you have built, I handle this as part of custom website projects, and you can get in touch to talk it through.
Written with AI assistance. The angle, the argument and the editorial direction of this article are mine: I brainstormed and shaped it. The drafting was done with AI, and I reviewed and edited the final text before publishing.